Exit Interview: The Team Behind TWO STRANGERS (CARRY A CAKE ACROSS NEW YORK) Say Farewell To Broadway
Ten years ago: two childhood friends sat down to write a musical. So began the humble journey of Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York), if only inside the minds of its co-composers, lyricists and book writers Jim Barne and Kit Buchan.
Three years ago: Two Strangers debuted in London at the Kiln Theatre, now under the guiding directorial hand of Tim Jackson. Buoyed by critical acclaim and a passionate fan following, the show swiftly transferred to the West End.
One year ago today: Two Strangers arrived in New York, following an out-of-town run at the A.R.T. in Boston and led by Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts. Eight Tony Award nominations followed: nods for Barne and Buchan (lyrics, score and book), for Jackson (direction of a musical), for Tutty, and for Pitts.
And in nine days, another stage of this show’s unlikely journey reaches its end, as Two Strangers concludes its Broadway run.
More is still to come. Two Strangers will begin a National Tour in the fall of 2027, kicking off in Providence, Rhode Island and continuing onto cities across the U.S. and Canada.
As New York bids farewell to Two Strangers, Theatrely sat down with the fab five—Barne, Buchan, Jackson, Tutty and Pitts—to discuss post-Tony hangovers, bouts with shingles, on-stage disasters, and saying goodbye.
THEATRELY: First of all, congratulations to you all on the Grammy Award nomination for Best Musical Theatre Album! Did that come as a surprise?
KIT BUCHAN (CO-COMPOSER, LYRICIST & BOOK WRITER): That one is for you, Jimbo.
JIM BARNE (CO-COMPOSER, LYRICIST & BOOK WRITER): I entered it for the Grammys, I have to come clean. But it wasn’t looking good! I’d been on the Reddit threads. I was like, there’s no way this is gonna happen.
KIT: We’re really proud of that album because we did it ourselves, with our friend and orchestrator Lux Pyramid. We didn’t have a record label. We all did a lot of heavy lifting to get it to the level where it could compete with bigger budget musical theater records. So it’s a really nice moment for us.
I know the London recording was already out there, so maybe it was a tougher sell. But we need to have Christiani on there, and you also rewrote the show quite substantially.
KIT: The score is meaningfully different to the point where it merited another album. And we all feel that the show found its final form in America. So we would have been sad to have not set that in amber.

Kit, Jim and Tim, talk me through the last few months for you guys. After all the Tonys and award season craziness has died down, and you’re back home in the UK. How does it feel to be less present, as the show settles in for a run?
JIM: You’re out there building the show with a team of people, and then they all turn around and say: “Alright then, cya later!” I mean obviously, it’s lovely to know that the show is happening elsewhere. But it is strange.
TIM JACKSON (DIRECTOR & CHOREOGRAPHER): I have felt really far away. I love everyone over at the Longacre, the cast, the band, to a person. If I lived in New York, I would swing by that building a lot more just to say, “Hi!” I might not have watched the show every night, because that would have made Sam and Christiani want to kill me.
How do you recall the post-Tonys experience?
KIT: When we were first nominated at the Tonys, we just thought, “That’s lovely!” And then, through the process of campaigning and meeting everybody, we came to want a prize. So we suffered a bit when we didn’t get one—or I did. Somebody had told us, “If you don’t win a Tony Award, you will immediately close.” So I was prepared for this grief, a bereavement that didn’t arrive.
And then I had a kind of euphoria! We were so relieved that the show carried on running, and proud of that. And I was really proud of Sam and Christiani, who had to go through that whole experience and then get straight back on stage, practically the following night.
TIM: It’s a lovely thing to know that the show is in such safe hands.
Sam and Christiani, how do you help each other stay sane, both during and after awards season craziness? Are you two sick of each other yet?
CHRISTIANI PITTS: We can still stand each other. Which I think is so cool. Sam and I both live very close to the theater, so we walk home together every night, and get it all out on that walk. We were just saying the other night: “Man, if we didn’t have this…”
SAM TUTTY: The summer was specifically difficult for me, that post-Tonys hangover. It was such a ridiculous circus—just the level of workload was unfathomable. The happy product is that you get to meet all these amazing people and develop actual friendships with other artists, in loads of different fields, because you’re just all put into this circuit.
So that was a crazy, crazy time. Me and Christiani have got an unbelievable friendship that I’m very grateful for, and that walk home has become such an amazing therapy and venting session.
CHRISTIANI: The rats that we encounter along the way…they get all of the tea.
Sam, you’ve been on a three-year journey with Dougal. How does it feel to be nearing the end?
SAM: Two Strangers has become a part of my life in the same way that brushing my teeth has. I will never not brush my teeth, therefore I will never not do this show. The idea of it coming to an end…I’m waiting for this wave of emotion that’s gonna hit me in, like, March of next year. It has been a privilege. I’m going to miss it so much.
Are you going to miss the city, though? Because you did post on social media, amidst one of several bouts with sickness, that you were possibly “allergic to New York.”
SAM: I love New York, I think it’s an amazing city, but I genuinely think my body doesn’t. If you name a sickness, honestly, dating back to Victorian times, I’ve had it.
KIT: Housemaid’s Knee…
Yeah there was one I remember seeing — did you have scurvy at one point…?
SAM: Shingles! I had shingles!
KIT (laughing): Scurvy!!
JIM: Did you have gout, Sam?
SAM: I became a pirate for a bit, yeah.
My research is on point. Sorry, I meant shingles.
SAM: That came out of nowhere. I thought I had spider bites on my back, and then Rachel, our amazing wardrobe supervisor, was like, “Sam, isn’t that…shingles..?” I was like, “Ha! I don’t have shingles!” And then I was out for nearly two weeks in the most agonizing pain I’ve ever experienced.
KIT: Sam, you are allowed to say that you’re looking forward to it being over, by the way.
SAM: Oh, no. There’s so many things I’m looking forward to, sure. I miss home, I miss England, I miss my loved ones. But there’s so much pull back to New York. Very sad, but very happy, but very sad.

I’m wondering how you all reflect on Robin’s trajectory as a character, first over the course of your Boston run, and then on Broadway. How did she grow and deepen as the show found its final form?
KIT: The show has been on in six different theaters over the past ten years, and at each stage, it needed to go through a process of maturation. When it went across to America, that was a terrifying increase in expectation. And that crystallized around the character of Robin, because she’s a New Yorker. We felt like, if we don’t do right by this character, we’re going to be laughed out of town.
From the first day that we met in Boston for rehearsals, we felt this immense emotional intelligence in Christiani. She already felt there was something in the character that spoke to her, and I felt so proud of that, and I wanted to earn that respect. The extent to which the character has emerged as Black, American woman living in New York in a way that has spoken to audience members living that experience, we have to share that with Christiani.
How would you say Robin changed?
KIT: For a while, the character had this slightly generic coldness. Maybe it was something we formulaically associated with New Yorkers. Whereas the Robin you see on stage now has a certain arms-lengthness about her, yes, a toughness and an independence—but she is also profoundly warm and humane from the moment we meet her.
TIM: I was looking, in Robin, for warmth at all stages. Because the coldness was going to exist in the text anyway. But actually, everyone at their core has so much light. It’s just how many layers you’ve put in between that core and the outside world.
KIT: This applies to Sam as well. There’s a woundedness and a childishness to Dougal, but he is also an adult, and Sam is an extremely intelligent performer, and wouldn’t have settled for a character that felt like a cartoon.
CHRISTIANI: I was so excited, because not only did I feel like, “I know this person,” but also I hadn’t seen that person on stage. So what has been really fun for me, as Robin has gotten deeper and deeper, is probing that heartbreak. Those little bits of her warmth coming out, and that she’s responsible for putting them back in, is so heartbreaking.
How does it feel to say goodbye to Robin?
CHRISTIANI: I don’t know the likelihood of me coming across a character like this on stage again. But I’m so grateful that there’s going to be young Black girls out there singing these songs. And having that conversation of, “I need to hop into my joy here.” The complexity of emotions that young Black actresses will get to have because of this piece moving forward…I’m very grateful it’s out there now, and I can’t wait to see the Robins to come.
Has your 3 year-old daughter been able to see you in the show?
CHRISTIANI: My daughter has seen the show. My daughter loves the show. And unfortunately, one of her favorite songs is, “On the App.” And, oh my goodness, there was this day where she went: "Momma, I want to hear “Rick the dick machine!” I said, “Oh Jesus, there must be another song we can sing.” But it’s her favorite song in the show.
SAM: Or at least another line in the show.
CHRISTIANI: I mean, why is that the one? “Rick the dick machine…”

We should mention the full company of standbys backstage at the Longacre: Phoenix Best, Jana Larell Glover, Vincent Michael and Austin Colburn.
CHRISTIANI: Everybody has their take on the characters. It’s like shopping. I will hear something that Jana or Phoenix have done, and I’ll be like, “Absolutely, putting that in my cart.” We’re inspired by each other.
SAM: Our friendship has genuinely pulled us through some of the harder times, where the nature of a two-hander is starting to really sit on your back in an uncomfortable way. We’ll just have a little mother’s meeting for 10 minutes upstairs, and then suddenly the room’s lighter, and I feel very loved, and I’m ready to do the next show.
CHRISTIANI: Sometimes the people getting the flowers are just the people on this call right now, but they hold the same responsibility to put this thing on its feet. And to still give a breathtaking performance.
SAM: There have been multiple times where I’ve given Vinny seconds of notice. Where my body has at the eleventh hour just crumbled. I’ll be throwing up in the toilet, and Vinny’s just like, “No worries!” Puts his stuff on, and off he goes. It’s crazy. It’s literally crazy.
KIT: Neither of them is off-stage for longer than three minutes. And they’re always singing! The two of you must hear other actors complain and be like, “You have no fucking idea.”
SAM: I was a bit of a nightmare at the Tonys, I was definitely in rooms going, “I’m exhausted.” And then if anyone said anything…
Do we have a running count on the suit drop, as we get towards the end?
SAM (deadpan): Why are you bringing this up?
Sam is annoyed.
SAM: It has been remarkably low, I’ll say that. No less than maybe 10 times have I dropped it. Out of like, 400? So…
KIT: Have you ever tried to catch it with your mouth?
SAM: Honestly, that’s tonight’s show.
TIM: Next time we see him, he’s got no teeth left.

Has the cake drop ever gone wrong? It’s so pivotal, and it makes me nervous every time.
CHRISTIANI: Never.
TIM: Never.
CHRISTIANI: Knock on all the wood.
TIM: Never ever.
CHRISTIANI: We inch it, and Sam and I both look at each other like, “Oh shit, move it over a little bit…”
SAM: To speak on that, one of the most amazing experiences for me is the ability Christiani and I have developed to communicate with each other on stage. We’ve had full conversations during scenes, with our eyes. Maybe she says her line too early and gives me a little eye to say, “Sorry,” and I give her a little eye back to say, “Don’t worry about it!”
CHRISTIANI: But I never say my lines early, he was just using an example…
SAM: If anyone says their lines early, it’s me!
CHRISTIANI: No no, we’ve had moments. Specifically in the Tinder song, something happened where I messed up. And if it wasn’t Sam’s line next, we would still be sitting on the subway now, waiting for something else to happen. I was profusely scared. I was sweating.
SAM: It was, “What about Rudy,” wasn’t it?
CHRISTIANI: Baby, I don’t know what it was. Or, one time I sang the wrong lyric in a solo, I was fresh off vacation, and my body just shut down. Just, silent, staring at Sam. Who is also silent, staring at me like: “I love you so much, and there’s nothing I can do.” And then all you hear is Ted Arthur, our conductor, do a little note, like, “Plink!”
SAM: Just sing anything.
CHRISTIANI: But you know, we got through it. I sang. Maybe five minutes later, but I did sing.
KIT: We should also mention the band, who have been with us from the beginning. They are performers too, and they build out the populated environment of this show. Lee Nadel, Rocky Bryant, Kevin Ramessar, Jesse Linden and Ted, our conductor. Just insanely brilliant. We’re going to miss them so much.
What are your final reflections on this wild journey?
JIM: You don’t really know when a piece of art is going to resonate. You do everything you can to make it something that you would want to see. Everybody is doing that. And sometimes it just doesn’t function. And it’s really nice that, for whatever reason, this one did. It’s been such a special experience.
KIT: On a personal level, Jim and I are a bit like Dougal in the sense that we have this very worshipful relationship with New York, and maybe some deep yearning to belong there. One could read this whole thing as a very convoluted, unconscious process to create the conditions in which we could have a home in this extraordinary place.
With the passing of years it will only become more astonishing to me that we got to create that home for ourselves in New York, at least temporarily, and perhaps forever. And that the city has embraced us. In that way New York does invite people into its bosom, once in a while.
TIM: I think back to the beginning of this, and the amount of people that have contributed is staggering, from tiny workshops and readings all the way to being at the Longacre. It has been a massive journey with so many people giving so much of themselves. I do think it’s a testament to you, Kit and Jim, because you’ve written something that has ignited people’s artistic fires in a really big way. So many people have responded to this really beautiful piece of work. I’m so grateful that it came into my life, and I will forever be grateful.













