Pink Is The Word, MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING On Broadway — Review

Broadway

Photo: Marc Brenner

By
Joey Sims
No items found.
on
November 19, 2026 10:20 PM
Category:
Reviews

Jamie Lloyd’s season-long Broadway residency at the Winter Garden Theatre officially kicks off tonight, and honestly? I say we hand over the keys. Even a semi-successful Lloyd joint, as this colorful, dance-filled take on William Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing ultimately proves to be, is still far more invigorating than most contemporary Broadway spectacles. 

Best known in New York for his video-forward take on Andrew Lloyd Weber’s Sunset Boulevard, this modernist British auteur is laying claim to the historic Winter Garden for the full 2026-27 season. Gird your loins for next spring, when Jamie’s House will be home to his Rachel Zegler-led Evita, direct from a celebrated West End run. 

But first up is Lloyd’s extravagant soirée of a Much Ado, headlined by high-wattage Marvel stars Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell. Also imported from London, this giddily silly production lives somewhere in between play and party. If Sunset was video-forward in concept, this one might be called confetti-forward. 

All of that glorious pink confetti, blanketing the Winter Garden stage and cascading from above in Soutra Gilmour’s colorful design, serves as happy reminder that not all spectacle is about huge set pieces. For all his minimalist tendencies, Lloyd is a very capable showman, and damn if the man doesn't know how to fill a Broadway house. As confetti flies, disco lights flash and oversized backdrops drop in—most delightfully, an enormous inflatable heart—it’s impossible to not be awed by the astonishing stagecraft on display. (Lighting design is by Jon Clark; Gilmour also supplies the gorgeous costumes.) 

Now, is it all a bit tryhard, a bit desperate to please? Without a doubt. We are greeted with overeagerness, in the form of youthful “ushers” dancing giddily down the aisles and grinning madly as patrons maneuver into each row and squeeze possessions under their seats. At first, it’s a fun bit of pre-show mood setting. At least until we’re being instructed to do “the wave.” By the time lights go down, you’ll just feel exhausted on these young dancers’ behalf. 

But hey, that's the vibe. The vibe is party, and at least for the first act, Lloyd is sticking to it. The revelries never stop here in Messina, where Benedick (Hiddleston) has just returned, triumphant from battle, alongside nobleman Don Pedro (Gerald Kyd) and Pedro’s illegitimate brother Don John (Tim Steed). 

Quickly, the roguish Benedick and sharp-tongued Beatrice (Atwell), niece of welcoming host Leonato (Forbes Masson), reignite their flirtatious battle of wits. They banter; they boogie; they banter and boogie. For every scene transition, Lloyd inserts a rollicking dance break, all scored to 1990s club hits like “Fight for Your Right,” “The Rhythm of the Night,”  “Work It” and many more. 

It’s a good time, for a time. Lloyd crafts some astonishing stage images in this fast-moving first act, particularly when that giant inflatable heart gets involved. Judicious trims rid the play of extraneous subplot, keeping the action tight and focused. And at first, the revelry does have purpose. For a masquerade ball sequence, hilariously oversized animal masks tell us something about each character: romantic but naive Claudio (James Phoon) dons an astronaut helmet, Benedick is a dog (naturally), Beatrice wears the face of a smirking cat. 

Photo: Marc Brenner

Early signs of trouble come in a pivotal scene of trickery. Don Pedro and Leonato ensure Benedick overhears them discussing, falsely, the unrequited love held for him by Beatrice. It is quite important that Benedick truly believes he is unseen during the conversation, for the comedy if nothing else. But Lloyd dispenses with logic, and Hiddleston instead rolls around quite visibly in the confetti nearby. Farce does require readable stage geography, and the sequence is less funny for disregarding the basics of what, where and why. 

That looseness of place and time, the lack of context around what space we’re inhabiting, isn’t really a problem when it’s just Party Time. But Much Ado is built upon a sharp tonal shift in its second half, as an elaborate bit of trickery blows up young Claudio’s wedding to Leonato’s daughter, Hero (a very good Mara Huf) and bitter confrontations ensue. Ultimately, Lloyd has not built a world that is accommodating to this darker turn. And since we’ve been so happily clowning around, few of the characters feel fleshed out enough for us to suddenly invest more deeply. 

Another key problem is that Lloyd’s modern touches clash with the abject cruelty of the second act’s dramatics. Claudio’s cruel humiliation of Hero, set off by a false accusation of adultery, clash so horribly with the happy milieu that it’s near-impossible for Phoon to win us back. 

Nor can Leonata’s revenge trick, his fooling Claudio and Don Pedro into believing Hero dead, be played as some empowering moment for the abused Hero.  Lloyd does give her a moment of fiery rebuke later on, but only a moment. In the world Lloyd has built, whatever that world is exactly, she wouldn’t take him back. But that’s not the play, so, we do what we can. 

Overcoming all these obstacles are the stars themselves, Hiddleston and Atwell, who are the beating heart at this production’s center. Hiddleston coasts a bit on his Loki charm, though that ends up being a meta play on Lloyd’s part, as Beatrice powerfully calls Benedick out on the same very tendency. And Atwell is simply radiant, her quiet melancholy sitting naturally alongside an effortless allure. She carries, effortlessly, what Lloyd’s production ultimately lacks: that natural balance of dark and light, happy and sad, all the confusing contradictions in natural coexistence. 

Much Ado About Nothing is now in performances on Broadway. For tickets and more information, visit here.

No items found.
Joey Sims

Joey Sims has written at The New York Times, The Brooklyn Rail, Vulture, IGN, TheaterMania, American Theatre Magazine, Culturebot, New York Theatre Guide, No Proscenium, Sherwood, Extended Play, TDF Stages and Time Out. Joey is an alumnus of the Eugene O’Neill Theater Center’s National Critics Institute. He runs a theater substack called Transitions and co-hosts the theater podcast House Closed: Theater We Saw alongside his friend Connor Scully.

Tags:
Broadway
No items found.