Adam Wachter’s TARRYTOWN Is Headed Off-Broadway Just In Time For Spooky Season

Ice Berg Productions and Sierra Miliziano are set to bring Adam Wachter’s Tarrytown to New York for a limited engagement, with performances beginning October 16, 2025, at The Cell Theater running through October 25. This contemporary chamber musical reimagines Washington Irving’s The Legend of Sleepy Hollow as a psychological queer love triangle set in modern-day upstate New York. 

Ichabod Crane, a music teacher rebuilding his life, finds himself entangled with Katrina and Brom Van Brunt in a ninety-minute story of longing, desire, and identity. With a witty and deeply melodic score, Wachter crafts a poignant exploration of small-town restlessness and the haunting pull of connection. 

The three-person company includes Andrew Cekala as Ichabod, Maya Sistruck as Katrina and Jake Goz as Brom.

Directed by Noah Eisenberg, produced by Ice Berg Productions and Sierra Miliziano, with music direction by Michael Cuschieri, bringing Tarrytown to life includes Ethan Feil (Lighting Designer), Rose Goodman (Props Designer), AJ Hernandez (Costume Coordinator), Ryan O’Dea (Sound Designer), and Alex Rockey (Scenic Designer). Casting done by Patrick Maravilla with Marketing Consulting by Anthony Colon (Acting Out Consulting). 

Originally premiering in San Diego in 2017, where it won “Best New Musical” at the Craig Noel Awards, Tarrytown was featured in an MCC Theater reading directed by Michael Arden with Jeremy Jordan, Andy Mientus, and Krysta Rodriguez. A studio album of the piece was released in 2020 to benefit The Actors Fund. 

For tickets and more information, visit here.